How To Measure SEO Results & Impact For Your Ecommerce Brand

TL;DR

If you’re running an ecommerce brand, measuring SEO isn’t about hitting “#1 for keyword X” it’s about linking visibility and brand awareness to revenue. This post will walk you through the tools, metrics, and mindset to track SEO progress, focus your efforts on high-impact activities (the 80/20 rule), and build a simple performance report that clearly demonstrates ROI.

—-

I have been building and executing SEO strategies for the better part of 20 years now. I’ve seen a lot of changes over the years in regards to strategy and tactics, but one thing that very rarely changes is measurement. When I talk with potential clients, one of the most common questions I get is… “How do we measure SEO performance?” They obviously want to make sure that each dollar invested is used wisely and can be tied back to revenue generated for the business.

Without clear ties between SEO efforts and business outcomes, it’s hard to justify the budget, optimize the strategy, and show value to stakeholders. I put this post together to help you understand which metrics matter to your business, which tools to use to track those metrics, and how to pull it all together into a report that links SEO activity to your business goals. That way you’re not just counting clicks, you’re proving value.

When you’re finished going through this, you’ll know and understand these five things:

• How to apply the 80/20 rule to SEO measurement
• The three core “pillars” of SEO measurement for ecommerce (visibility, behaviour, and competitive)
• What counts as leading vs. lagging indicators in SEO
• How to build a straightforward SEO performance report
• Specific examples tailored for ecommerce brands (with direct-to-consumer relevance)

Let’s jump in!

What is the 80/20 Rule for SEO and Why it Matters for Measurement

The 80/20 rule for SEO (a version of the Pareto Principle) holds that roughly 20% of your SEO efforts will generate 80% of your results in terms of traffic and revenue. That means focusing measurement on the high-impact 20% is far more effective than trying to track every possible SEO metric. By identifying that critical 20% of optimization work and aligning the right metrics to it, you make your measurement far more meaningful and actionable for your team. Makes sense, right?

Setting the Stage: Why You Must Measure SEO Results

Measurement in SEO is not just about being able to see what changed, but to understand how your search visibility translates into business outcomes. It goes beyond vanity metrics like “we rank #1 for keyword Y”, which isn’t necessarily bad, but doesn’t tell you whether the effort is driving new customer sales for your brand. For a direct-to-consumer ecommerce brand, you must be able to show how organic search contributed to your bottom line, justified the investment, and revealed where to shift strategy. Regular tracking also helps you refine your organic strategy, spot new growth lever opportunities, and diagnose underperforming areas earlier.

The 3 Pillars of Effective SEO Measurement

To bring structure and clarity to your reporting, you’ll need to break out your SEO measurement into three core areas or “pillars.” Each pillar uses distinct tools and metrics, and together they cover the journey from search visibility to user behavior and competitive context.

Pillar 1: Visibility & Engagement with Google Search Console

Google Search Console (GSC) is your way to understand how Google sees your site in their search results. For SEO’s and brand marketers, you should be in there every day and using it as a primary source of truth for search visibility and user engagement.

Key metrics you’ll want to pull into your report are as follows:

• Impressions: How often your site appeared in search results (brand awareness)
• Clicks: How many users chose to click through to your site (search demand)
• Click-Through Rate (CTR): Clicks divided by impressions, showing how compelling your listing (title tag and meta descriptions) are.

Example: You recently launched a new product category on your Shopify website. You optimized the page, added killer content, and attracted some links and now you’re ranking for quite a few keywords. When you inspect the URL in GSC, you notice that you have high impressions for a target keyword but a low CTR. This tells you that you are indeed ranking for a given keyword, that people are seeing your website and brand, however you haven’t made it compelling enough for searchers to click through. This should give you enough insight to take a step back and work on optimizing your title tag/meta description, potentially adjusting schema markup, then submit for re-indexing and continuing to monitor.

Pillar 2: Traffic & Business Impact with Google Analytics

Google Analytics (GA4) gives you deeper insight into how users behave once they land on your website. In short, once a user clicks on your site from a search, analytics enable you to track their actions, whether they convert, and whether the session delivers business value.

For an ecommerce business, your focus should be on the following:

• Organic Traffic (volume): Number of visits from organic search
• Conversions / Sales: How many of those visits converted into sales
• Revenue: The ultimate KPI for DTC ecommerce (what those organic visits translated into in dollars)
• Engagement metrics: Such as engaged sessions, time on page, pages/session; these indicate content quality and UX relevance

Example: Your brand spends a significant amount of time producing high-quality, helpful blog content. This is content that is designed to answer questions and guide your customers through the buyer journey. When you dive into GA4, you notice that your blog posts generate a ton of organic traffic, but your engagement on those posts is low and conversions are very few. You need to decide if the blog is a brand awareness play or if it is a tool that should be optimized to lead customers to the bottom of the funnel product pages.

Pillar 3: Competitive Landscape with SEMrush

SEMrush (or similar tools like Ahrefs) helps you track things Google doesn’t directly provide: keyword ranking progression, competitive share, backlink growth, domain authority/authority score. These metrics shine light on your visibility in the market and the search engines.

Key metrics you’ll want to pay attention to:

• Keyword Rankings: Where your prioritized terms (volume + intent) currently rank in Google.
• Backlink Profile Growth: The number and quality of your inbound links.
• Domain Authority / Authority Score: A proxy for your site’s search engine “trust” and health. The higher the score, generally, the higher you will rank.

Example: You decided to do some competitive analysis one afternoon and noticed that your top competitor is consistently earning quality links from major publications and you see their authority score outpacing yours. This is a signal to you that in order to stay competitive in organic search, you may need to invest in some online PR or link-building outreach efforts.

Leading vs. Lagging Indicators: A Smarter Way to Track Progress

This one is fun. If you ever want to go deep into leading and lagging indicators, pick up a copy of The 4 Disciplines of Execution. It’s one of my favorites!

As a marketer (in any industry), understanding the difference between leading and lagging indicators helps you set realistic expectations and deliver meaningful reports, especially when it comes to SEO, since major revenue upticks most often lag behind ranking and traffic improvements.

Here’s a 30-second crash course:

• Leading Indicators: These are early signals that your strategy is working.
  • Example: Improved keyword rankings, higher organic impressions, and new quality backlinks. These do not yet show revenue, but they show movement.
• Lagging Indicators: These are business results that emerge after the leading indicators.
  • Example: Increased organic revenue, more qualified leads from organic, and higher average order value for organic sessions. These show that your SEO efforts converted into real business value.

Why This Matters: If you only report on lagging indicators (e.g., revenue), it might look like you’re not doing anything for several months… that is, until the revenue starts rolling in. Can you imagine how much anxiety this might cause stakeholders who are investing $5,000 per month into SEO? On the flip side, if you only report on leading indicators (e.g., rankings) without linking them to business goals, you risk being accused of tracking vanity metrics, which is never a fun discussion to have.

A balanced report includes both: “We saw keyword ranking improve (leading), which contributed to a 10% increase in organic traffic, and that yielded a 5% lift in online sales (lagging).”

How to Create a Simple SEO Performance Report in 4 Steps

Let’s build a practical, repeatable framework you can use every month (or quarter) to report SEO results for your ecommerce brand. The most important thing is to keep it simple and tied to business goals and outcomes.

Step 1: Start with Your Business Goals

Metrics are meaningless without context. Begin by anchoring everything to your business objective. Example mappings:

• Goal: Increase ecommerce sales → Key Metric: Organic Revenue
• Goal: Increase email subscribers to market to → Key Metric: Organic Form Submissions/Conversions
• Goal: Build brand awareness (for new market launch) → Key Metric: Impressions + Non-branded keyword rankings (visibility rather than immediate sales)

By selecting goals up front you force alignment between SEO measurement and business outcomes.

Step 2: Select Your Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

From the 3 pillars above, choose a handful of metrics that directly map to your goal. Make sure to avoid tracking everything… remember, less is more for clarity.

Aim for the following:

• 1-2 leading indicators (e.g., keyword ranking improvements for target terms)
• 1-2 lagging indicators (e.g., organic traffic volume and organic revenue)
• Optional one engagement indicator (e.g., organic conversion rate or average order value from organic traffic)

For example, if your goal is to increase online sales for a new product:

• Leading KPI: Rank in the top 10 for 5 target keywords
• Leading KPI: Increase organic impressions for product pages by 15%
• Lagging KPI: Increase organic sessions to product pages by 20%
• Lagging KPI: Increase organic revenue from those product pages by 25%

This limited set ensures focus, alignment, and a clear story.

Step 3: Gather and Compare Your Data (Month-over-Month)

Now go pull the data…

• In Google Search Console: extract impressions, clicks, CTR for targeted pages/keywords.
• In Google Analytics: pull organic traffic, sessions, conversions, and revenue (filter to organic channel).
• In SEMrush: record ranking positions for target keywords, backlink growth, and authority score.

Then, take time to dive in and compare the following: This month vs. last month, or this quarter vs. last quarter, whichever you find is the best cadence.

Make sure to highlight the trends: Is the movement in the right direction? Show both numbers and % change.

Example: “Organic sessions increased 12% month-over-month; organic revenue increased 8%.” If you track your coordinated leading and lagging metrics, you’ll show a chain of cause and effect.

Step 4: Tell the Story

In many cases, the numbers are necessary, but not 100% sufficient. The best marketers add a short narrative that ties everything together:

“This month we improved rankings for our target product-category keywords (leading indicator), by doing X, Y, and Z. As a result, impressions rose 18% and CTR improved from 3.2% to 4.1%. That drove a 12% uptick in organic sessions to those pages, and organic sales from those pages rose by 8%. Based on our average order value of $95, that equals an incremental $24 K in revenue attributable to SEO activity.”

Do you see how powerful that is, compared to just numbers?

When telling the story, make sure to use plain language, avoid jargon, and focus on outcomes, not just actions. Lastly, outline the next steps to continue moving things forward: e.g., “Next month we will optimize meta descriptions for under-performing pages and test internal linking to further boost CTR.”

That’s it. Easy peasy.

Moving Beyond Data to Drive Growth

I hope you’ve seen how effective SEO measurement for ecommerce brands is not just about collecting data, it’s about connecting it to your business growth. When you anchor your measurement to business goals, focus on high-impact activities (the 80/20 rule), and build a simple yet powerful report that tells a story, you shift SEO from “nice to have” to a measurable driver of revenue, visibility, and brand equity.

Remember to start simple: Choose one business goal, pick 3-4 KPIs (a mix of leading and lagging), pull your data this month, compare to last, and write a short narrative. Do it again next month. Over time, you’ll build momentum, report real wins, justify your budget (and probably grow it), and refine your SEO strategy with purpose.

Go get ‘er done!

Frequently Asked Questions On SEO Measurement

How long does it take to see SEO results?

SEO is a marathon, not a sprint. You’re not going to rank overnight, no mater how much you want to. For ecommerce brands, meaningful revenue-impacting results typically take 3-6 months and sometimes up to 12 months, depending on competition, site authority, and the scope of optimization. That said, you may see leading indicators (such as improved rankings or impressions) much sooner. By reporting both leading and lagging indicators, you manage expectations and demonstrate progress even before revenue jumps.

How do you know if your SEO is working?

You’ll know it’s working when you see positive, sustained trends across your main KPIs:

• Target keyword rankings are improving or holding strong
• Organic traffic is growing and/or converting better
• Engagement metrics improving (better CTR, longer time on site, higher conversion rates)
• Most importantly, an increase in revenue or qualified leads from the organic channel

If all you have is increased traffic but no improvement in conversions or revenue, you may be attracting irrelevant sessions or need to refine targeting and user experience.

How often should you monitor your SEO performance?

We check rankings every few days for clients, but for most ecommerce brands, a monthly reporting cadence hits the sweet spot. It’s frequent enough to catch trends and address issues, but not so frequent that you overreact to standard fluctuations. For a wider strategic review, a quarterly deep-dive is useful to assess broader performance, budget alignment, and next-phase planning. Daily tracking of individual metrics is fine for alerts (e.g., traffic collapse) but not meaningful for most reporting.

Greg Shuey

Greg is the founder and CEO of Stryde and a seasoned digital marketer who has worked with thousands of businesses, large and small, to generate more revenue via online marketing strategy and execution. Greg has written hundreds of blog posts as well as spoken at many events about online marketing strategy. You can follow Greg on Twitter and connect with him on LinkedIn.